Fire Needs a Vessel
Parshat Vayigash (the Torah portion of Vayigash) opens with Yehudah (Judah) stepping forward to speak to Egypt's ruler. The Me'or Einayim (Rabbi Menachem Nachum of Chernobyl) asks why this was written in the Torah.
2 minute readA verse says of the word of Hashem (God): "Is not My word like fire?" Nobody holds fire in a bare hand. If the Torah is fire, what would it have to come in?
He asks why the verse "And Yehudah approached him" was written in the Torah. It cannot be, Heaven forbid, only stories: the Zohar (the classic of the Torah's hidden teachings) curses those who say that the Torah is only stories. He brings a verse from Tehillim (Psalms), "You have clothed Yourself in glory and splendor," and reads it this way: the splendor is the Torah (so the print; see Go deeper), and "You have clothed" means that the Creator clothed the Torah in garments. For the Torah is called fire. As it is impossible to hold fire without garments, so the Torah cannot be held without a vessel. Therefore it had to be clothed in garments and vessels.
Read it in his wordsThe Me'or Einayim in Hebrew, with our English
A story you know by heart is still holding something
You know this story. You were in it once, in fourth grade, as the third brother from the left, with a towel on your head and no lines. Yehudah steps forward, Yosef (Joseph) cannot hold himself back, and weeps aloud. When the parsha comes around, it is easy to nod at it the way one nods at a rerun.
The Me'or Einayim asks why this was written in the Torah, and says it cannot be only a story. The Torah is called fire, he says, and fire cannot be held without something around it. So the Torah had to be clothed in garments and vessels.
In our words: this page does not know what you saw from under the towel. We take only his picture. The fire is held by its garment, and the garment is there because of what is in it. The Zohar he points to says it of the Torah's stories: the story is the garment, and one looks at what is under it. The towel, for the record, was your sister's.
Read the first verses of Parshat Vayigash today (Bereishit, Genesis, 44:18 and on) as if you did not know the ending. Ask what one line is there to teach you.
Ask yourself, or your study partnerWhich story in the Torah do I know so well that I have stopped reading it?
Go deeperMore of the teaching, and every source
It cannot be only stories
He names the Zohar and gives no place in it. The passage that fits his words is in the Zohar's section on the Torah portion Beha'alotcha (3:152a). Rabbi Shimon (bar Yochai) says there: woe to the person who says that the Torah came to tell mere stories and everyday words. All the words of the Torah, he says, are high words and high secrets. The story of the Torah, the Zohar says, is the Torah's garment, and it goes on, in harsher words, about one who thinks that the garment is the Torah itself and nothing more. It gives a picture of its own: wine sits only in a jar, and the Torah sits only in this garment. So one should look only at what is under the garment.
Clothed in splendor
The print says "and splendor" (hadar), though the verse he brings as proof says "glory" (hod). The first verse is Tehillim (Psalms) 104:1. The second, "Set Your glory upon the heavens," is Tehillim 8:2. We add where the Sages read that verse as speaking of the Torah. In the Gemara (the Talmud, Shabbat 88b) Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi tells that when Moshe (Moses) went up to receive the Torah, the angels said this verse before the Holy One, blessed be He: they asked that the Torah stay in heaven.
Fire
The verse is Yirmiyahu (Jeremiah) 23:29: "Is not My word like fire, says Hashem, and like a hammer that shatters rock?" We add: the Gemara (Taanit 7a) asks why words of Torah are compared to fire, and gives a reason of its own. Rabbah bar bar Chanah says there: as fire does not burn alone, so words of Torah do not last in one who learns alone.
Where the teaching goes
He opens with the verse "And Yehudah approached him" (Bereishit, Genesis, 44:18) and asks why it was written. The teaching as printed breaks off before its end (see the seventh step). The verse is not mentioned again in what is printed.
Sources
- Me'or Einayim, Vayigash 1: why this was written; the Torah is called fire, and is clothed in garments.
- Bereishit 44:18: "And Yehudah approached him."
- Zohar, Beha'alotcha (3:152a): the story of the Torah is its garment.
- Tehillim 104:1: "You have clothed Yourself in glory and splendor."
- Tehillim 8:2: "Set Your glory upon the heavens."
- Shabbat 88b: the angels say this verse when Moshe goes up for the Torah.
- Yirmiyahu 23:29: "Is not My word like fire."
- Taanit 7a: why words of Torah are compared to fire.