Does the psalm really say God made a sea monster to play with?
Verse 26 says God formed Leviathan "lesachek bo." The little word bo can mean "with it" or "in it," so the line can mean "to play with" or "to play in it." Leviathan is a giant sea creature, and the psalm sets it right next to the ships and the fish. Read the first way, it can sound like a joke slipped into a prayer.
The Gemara (the central book of rabbinic discussion) takes it seriously. Rav Yehuda says in the name of Rav, a leading sage in Babylon about 1,800 years ago, that God's day has four parts of three hours. First God studies Torah. Then He judges the world, and if He sees the world deserves destruction, He moves from the seat of justice to the seat of mercy. Then He feeds the whole world, "from the horns of wild oxen to the eggs of lice." Last, He plays with Leviathan, and this verse is the proof.
Rashi (the French commentator of the 1000s) quotes this Gemara on our verse. He adds a line from Iyov (Job) 40:29, where God, speaking out of a storm, asks Iyov about Leviathan: "Will you play with him like a bird?"
Others read bo the other way. Radak says Leviathan was made to play in the sea, among all the sea creatures, since all of them are in its power. Metzudat David says the same: it roams and plays in that sea and fears no creature, because the others are its food.
In Avodah Zarah the Gemara is really asking whether God ever laughs. Rav Nachman bar Yitzchak draws a line: God plays with His creatures, but laughs at them only on one day. The sources we opened do not choose between "God plays with Leviathan" and "Leviathan plays in the sea." Both readings are old.
Tehillim 104:26,Avodah Zarah 3b,Rashi on Tehillim 104:26,Radak and Metzudat David on Tehillim 104:26,Iyov 40:29The psalm says God feeds every animal. So why do creatures go hungry?
Verses 27 and 28 say every creature looks to God to give it food in its time. "You open Your hand, they are filled with good." So why is anyone hungry? The Ashrei page asks this about almost the same words in Ashrei. This psalm, and one sage who read it, add two things.
First, the psalm itself does not say feeding is automatic. The next verse says: "You hide Your face, they are terrified." Radak says hiding God's face means holding back their food. He also says the food comes through a chain of causes, and that it is in God's hand to give or to hold back.
Second, Rabbi Shimon ben Elazar, a sage of about 1,800 years ago, looks at the same picture from the other side. He says he has never seen a deer drying figs, a lion working as a porter, or a fox running a shop, and yet they get their food without hardship. They were made to serve him, and he was made to serve his Maker. So why does he struggle for a living? His answer: "I have spoiled my deeds and cut off my own livelihood." He says it about himself, and he backs it with Yirmeyahu (Jeremiah) 5:25: "Your wrongs have turned these things away."
So the sources give a few answers. Food comes through causes. It can be held back. One sage blames his own deeds. None of the sources we opened explains why a particular person or animal goes hungry. That question stays open.
Tehillim 104:27-29,Radak on Tehillim 104:27 and 104:29,Kiddushin 82b,Yirmeyahu 5:25Everything in this psalm dies and gets replaced. Is that meant to comfort me?
Verses 29 and 30 sit side by side. First: "You hide Your face, they are terrified. You gather in their breath, they die and return to dust." Then: "You send Your breath, they are created, and You renew the face of the earth." The first part of this prayer tells how the Gemara linked verse 29 to the day of death.
Who is being created in verse 30? Rashi says it is the resurrection of the dead.
Radak gives that reading first. He says that in our belief, this is the resurrection, and it will come as a wonder, not through nature. Then he adds a second way to read the verse, about all living things and not only people. When these die, others are born in their place, as Kohelet (Ecclesiastes) says: a generation goes and a generation comes. In his words, the kinds stay standing and the individuals are lost. "Renew the face of the earth" would then be the new ones arriving.
Midrash Tehillim ties the verse to what comes next. When does God send His breath? When He renews the face of the earth. At that hour: "May the glory of Hashem last forever," which is the next verse of this prayer.
Neither reading says dying is nothing. The psalm's own word for creatures at that moment is "terrified." Then, in the next verse, it turns to creation.
Tehillim 104:29-30,Rashi and Radak on Tehillim 104:30,Kohelet 1:4,Midrash Tehillim 104:19