When the Messiah comes, will we still need to remember Egypt?
Most of this prayer retells the Exodus, and you say it every night. The Mishnah says the Exodus is mentioned at night, and records an argument about it. Rabbi Elazar ben Azarya (a leading sage of the Mishnah) says he was "like a seventy-year-old" and had never managed to prove that the Exodus must be mentioned at night, until Ben Zoma (another sage) explained a verse.
Devarim 16:3 says to remember the day you left Egypt "all the days of your life." "The days of your life" means the days. The extra word "all" adds the nights. Rashi says the Mishnah means the tzitzit paragraph of the Shema, which ends with the Exodus.
The other sages in the Mishnah read "all" differently. "The days of your life" is this world, and "all" adds the days of the Messiah. So in their view the Exodus is remembered even then.
The Gemara (Berakhot 12b) has Ben Zoma push back. Will the Exodus be mentioned in the days of the Messiah? The prophet Yirmeyahu said days are coming when people will no longer say, "As Hashem lives who brought Israel out of Egypt," but "who brought the descendants of Israel back from the land of the north" and from all the lands.
The sages answer: the Exodus will not be uprooted from its place. It will become secondary, and the later rescue will be the main one. The Gemara compares it to Yaakov's name. God told him, "Your name will no longer be called Yaakov, but Yisrael" (Bereishit 35:10). It says that does not mean Yaakov disappears. Yisrael becomes the main name, and Yaakov is second.
Then the Gemara gives a picture. A man on the road meets a wolf and escapes, and keeps telling the wolf story. Then a lion, and he tells the lion story. Then a snake, and now he tells only the snake story. The Gemara's lesson: the later troubles make Israel forget the earlier ones.
Ben Zoma held it would not be mentioned then. The Sages answered that it stays, as a smaller story beside a bigger one.
Mishnah Berakhot 1:5,Berakhot 12b-13a,Rashi on Berakhot 12b,Devarim 16:3,Yirmeyahu 23:7-8,Bereishit 35:10Did Israel leave Egypt at night or in the morning?
It matters here because this is the evening version of the blessing, and the Torah seems to say both. Devarim 16:1 says Hashem "took you out of Egypt at night." Bamidbar 33:3 says Israel left "the day after the Pesach offering, with a high hand." And in Shemot 12:22 Moshe tells the people not to go out of their house door until morning.
The Gemara (Berakhot 9a) quotes Rabbi Abba: everyone agrees that Israel was redeemed only at night, and that they left only in the daytime. A teaching in the same passage reads the verse "at night" as meaning that the redemption began for them from the evening. The Torah does say that Pharaoh called Moshe and Aharon at night and told them to go (Shemot 12:31).
The same passage of the Gemara asks why Israel was told to ask the Egyptians for gold and silver. The answer goes back to a promise to Avraham: his descendants would be enslaved and oppressed, "and afterward they will leave with great wealth" (Bereishit 15:13-14). God did not want Avraham to be able to say that the first half came true and the second half did not. The people answered, "If only we could just get out ourselves."
Then the Gemara gives a picture. A man is in prison. People tell him, "Tomorrow we will take you out and give you a lot of money." He says, "Please, take me out today. I ask for nothing."
Notice what the Gemara does not do. It does not pick a time and drop the other verse. It splits the event: the freedom began at night, and the walking out came in the morning. The Emet Veyatziv page tells how Abudarham (a commentary on the prayers, Spain, about 1340) ties this blessing's name, "faithful," to that night, when Israel trusted God's promise to take them out in the morning.
Devarim 16:1,Bamidbar 33:3,Shemot 12:22, 12:31,Berakhot 9a-9b,Bereishit 15:13-14,Abudarham, Blessings on the ShemaThe prayer says God never lets our foot slip. Is that true?
Read the line again: "He sets our soul in life and did not let our foot slip." It sounds like a promise that nothing goes wrong. Jewish history, and a lot of ordinary life, does not look like that. The sources read the line more carefully.
It is a verse, Tehillim 66:9. Look at the verses right after it. "You tested us, You refined us like silver. You brought us into the net. You put a heavy load on our backs. You let a man ride over our heads. We went through fire and water, and You brought us out to abundance" (66:10-12). The psalm that says "our foot did not slip" also says we went through fire and water.
Radak (a medieval commentator on Tehillim) reads verse 9 as something said afterward. He says it means God "left us alive in exile," and that the survivors of Israel will say "our foot did not slip" after the refining. He points to Zecharyah 13:9, where God brings a third of the people through fire and refines them like silver. On "fire and water," he says trouble is compared to fire that burns and water that sweeps away, and we went into both in our exile and were not finished off.
Abudarham reads it more narrowly. For him the line is about one night, the night of the last plague, when Israel's firstborn did not die with Egypt's. He ties it to Tehillim 121:3, "He will not let your foot slip; your Guardian does not sleep."
Neither reading says that nobody ever stumbles. One says the people were not wiped out. The other says that on one night, Israel was guarded. The line just before it in the prayer, "He does great things beyond searching out," comes from the book of Iyov (Job), which Iyov says in the middle of his losses. See the card on Iyov.
These sources do not explain why a particular person suffers. What they say the line claims is survival, not an easy road.
Tehillim 66:9-12,Radak on Tehillim 66:9 and 66:12,Zecharyah 13:9,Abudarham, Weekday Prayers, Evening Service,Tehillim 121:3