Why call judges godlike, then say they will die like everyone else?
Verses 6 and 7 are the strangest part. "I said: you are elohim, sons of the Most High, all of you. But in truth, you will die like humans, and fall like one of the princes." The sources disagree about who is being addressed and what the fall is.
Radak says the judges themselves. A judge who rules truthfully is rightly called elohim, and God hoped they would be that, like the angels, who are also called "sons of the Most High." But Radak sees them ruining the high rank of their souls, so they will die like any ordinary person.
Ibn Ezra (a Spanish commentator who died in the 1160s) puts it differently. Your souls are like the souls of angels, he says, but you are no more than bodies, and bodies die.
Rashi reads "elohim" as angels, and the speaker as God at Mount Sinai. The Gemara has Rabbi Yosei teach that Israel accepted the Torah so that the Angel of Death would no longer rule over them, and he proves it from this verse (Avodah Zarah 5a). Rashi then reads "like humans" as "like Adam," since they spoiled their deeds as he did. Midrash Tehillim also reads the verse through Adam: he got one command, did not keep it, and was sent out of Eden.
So there are three readings: judges who fall from a high rank, souls like angels inside bodies that die, and a people who lost a gift given at Sinai. They share one shape, a high calling followed by a drop. The psalm does not spell out the drop, and each commentator fills it in his own way.
Radak on Tehillim 82:6-7,Ibn Ezra on Tehillim 82:6-7,Rashi on Tehillim 82:6-7,Avodah Zarah 5a,Midrash Tehillim 82:3Can one unfair ruling really shake "the foundations of the earth"?
The psalm says judges "do not know and do not understand, they walk about in darkness," and because of it "all the foundations of the earth shake." A bad ruling in one courtroom seems small next to that.
Rashi explains the darkness. Because of this wrong, he says, the judges walk in darkness, the way "a bribe blinds." That is the Torah's rule "do not take a bribe, for a bribe blinds those who see clearly" (Shemot 23:8). A judge who bends the law loses the ability to see what is right.
Radak reads the words at full size. He says the judges' acts could bring the world down, and he recalls that the flood came because of chamas. The Torah says that before the flood "the earth was filled with chamas" (Bereishit 6:11), and Rashi says that word means robbery.
The Gemara has a similar idea. Rabbi Yose ben Elisha (a rabbi from the time of the Mishnah) taught that if you see a generation with many troubles, go and check its judges, because every punishment that came into the world came because of Israel's judges. He proves it from the prophet Michah, who accused the leaders of judging for bribes (Shabbat 139a).
Pirkei Avot (the Mishnah's book of sayings on ethics) states the positive version: the world stands on three things, on justice, on truth and on peace (1:18). The Hashivah Shofteinu prayer, the blessing about judges in the Amidah, tells more about that line.
None of these sources explains how a single verdict does it. What they share is the claim that the state of the world depends on whether its courts are fair.
Rashi on Tehillim 82:5,Shemot 23:8,Radak on Tehillim 82:5,Bereishit 6:11 and Rashi,Shabbat 139a,Pirkei Avot 1:18I will never be a judge. What does a psalm about courts have to do with me?
The Torah's rule for fair judging is not in a section addressed only to judges. Vayikra 19:15 says: "Do not do injustice in judgment. Do not favor the poor and do not honor the great. In righteousness judge your fellow." It sits in a chapter that God tells Moshe to speak to the whole congregation of Israel.
Rashi spells out both halves. Do not say, "He is poor, and the rich man should support him anyway, so I will rule for the poor man." And do not say, "He is rich and from a good family, why embarrass him?" Either way you are bending the case. Midrash Tehillim says the same about our psalm: give the poor man his justice, but do not take from a rich man just because the other side is poor.
Then Rashi gives a second meaning for "in righteousness judge your fellow": judge your friend favorably. The Mishnah has the same instruction, in the name of Yehoshua ben Perachyah (a teacher who lived more than 2,000 years ago): judge every person favorably (Pirkei Avot 1:6).
Most people never sit on a court, but almost everyone decides, all the time, whose story to believe. The sources do not say that is what the psalm is about. They do say the Torah's call for fairness is addressed to everyone, and that one reading of it is about how you judge people you know.
Taking the psalm from the courtroom to your own life is a step the sources leave to you.
Vayikra 19:2 and 19:15,Rashi on Vayikra 19:15,Midrash Tehillim 82:2,Pirkei Avot 1:6