Me'or Einayim, Daily Parshat Miketz
Torah Tech torahtech.co/meor/miketz
Me'or Einayim · Parshat Miketz
מִקֵּץ

Seven days with the Chernobyler Maggid

One short teaching a day from the Me'or Einayim ("Light of the Eyes"), the book of Rabbi Menachem Nachum of Chernobyl (1730 to 1797), known as the Chernobyler Maggid, the preacher of Chernobyl. His words, what he means, and how to take it to work. About two minutes. Want more? Every day has a "Go deeper" section with more of the teaching and every source.

His words are in the dark boxes. Take it to work is our application of his idea.

Sunday, December 6 · Day 1 of 7

The Light in It

Parshat Miketz (the Torah portion of Miketz) opens, "And it was at the end of two years." The Me'or Einayim (Rabbi Menachem Nachum of Chernobyl) starts further back, with what the Torah was given for.

2 minute read
Think first

The prophet Yirmiyahu (Jeremiah) asks why the land of Israel was lost. The answer given: "because they left My Torah." But the Sages say that before the land was destroyed, seven courts of kings in it had worshipped idols. Why does the answer begin with the Torah, and not with the idols?

Today's teaching

The Torah was given to us, the Me'or Einayim says, because a person is "a Godly portion from above," and by means of the Torah a person can bring himself close to Hashem (God). And so, he says, the verse reads as it does. The prophet Yirmiyahu (Jeremiah) asks why the land was lost, and the answer is "because they left My Torah." The Sages count seven courts that worshipped idols. As long as they had not left the Torah, he says, they were not yet punished, for by the light in it they could return to the good. When they left the Torah, they were punished for those sins: there was nothing in them by which they could come back to Hashem.

Read it in his wordsThe Me'or Einayim in Hebrew, with our English
הנה התורה שנתנה לנו הוא כי האדם הוא חלק אלקי ממעל ועל ידי אמצעות התורה יוכל האדם לקרב את עצמו אל השם
"The Torah was given to us because a person is a Godly portion from above, and by means of the Torah a person can bring himself close to Hashem."
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 2Open the source
Take it to work

In a bad month, look at what you did not drop

It has been a bad month. You were late to Shacharit (the morning prayer) eleven times. Twice you were not late, because you were not there. One thing is still standing: forty minutes of learning one night a week with a chavruta (study partner). You have wondered why that one survived. Mostly, he calls you.

The Me'or Einayim points to seven courts that worshipped idols. While they had not left the Torah, he says, they were not yet punished: by the light in it they could still return to the good. Once they left it, there was nothing in them to come back by.

In our words: he is speaking of courts that worshipped idols, and a month of late mornings is not that. In his account they still held the Torah while they sinned, and while they held it they had a way back. So the forty minutes a week are not leftovers from a better month. They may be where the next one starts. And where nothing was kept, a first piece can be picked up today. Your chavruta will call.

Today's move

Name the one piece of Torah learning you kept through your busiest month. Put its next session in your calendar now. If you kept none, choose one small piece and put its first session there.

Send to a friend

Ask yourself, or your study partnerWhat is the one piece of learning I have kept, or could keep, when everything else slips?

Go deeperMore of the teaching, and every source

The question and its answer

The verses are Yirmiyahu (Jeremiah) 9:11-12: "Who is the wise man who will understand this… for what was the land lost?" and then, "And Hashem said: because they left My Torah, which I set before them." In the Gemara (the Talmud, Nedarim 81a) Rav Yehudah says in the name of Rav that this question was asked of the sages and of the prophets, and they did not explain it, until the Holy One, blessed be He, explained it Himself, in the next verse. The Gemara then gives Rav's explanation of the verse's last words, "and did not walk in it": they did not first say the blessing over the Torah. The Me'or Einayim uses the Gemara's phrase, "until the Holy One, blessed be He, Himself explained it," and then takes the verse in the way of the Midrash (the Sages' readings of the verses), below.

Seven courts

ושבעה בתי דינין שעבדו עבודה זרה כל זמן שלא עזבו את התורה ועל ידי המאור שבה יוכלו לחזור למוטב לא נענשו עדיין ובעזבם את התורה נענשו על עבירות הנ״ל שלא היה בהם דבר שיוכלו לחזור ולשוב אל השם
"And the seven courts that worshipped idols: as long as they had not left the Torah, and by the light in it they could return to the good, they were not yet punished. And when they left the Torah, they were punished for those sins, for there was nothing in them by which they could return and come back to Hashem."
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 2Open the source

The seven courts are from the Gemara (Gittin 88a). Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi says there that the land of Israel was not destroyed until seven courts had worshipped idols in it, and he names seven kings, from Yerovam ben Nevat to Hoshea ben Elah.

The light in it

The words are from Eichah Rabbah, the Midrash on the book of Lamentations, in its second opening. On the verse "They left Me, and did not keep My Torah" (Yirmiyahu 16:11), Rabbi Huna and Rabbi Yirmeyah say in the name of Rabbi Chiya bar Abba: "If only they had left Me and kept My Torah. Through occupying themselves with it, the light in it would have brought them back to the good." The same passage says, in the name of Rabbi Shmuel bar Rabbi Yitzchak, that the Holy One overlooked idol worship, forbidden relations and bloodshed, and did not overlook the rejection of the Torah, since the verse says only "because they left My Torah." In the Jerusalem Talmud (Chagigah 1:7) the line reads: "the leaven in it would have brought them close to Me."

A Godly portion from above

His words are chelek Eloki mima'al, "a Godly portion from above." They are built on a verse in Iyov (Job) 31:2, "And what is the portion of God [chelek Eloka] from above?" The Tanya, a Chasidic book by Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi, opens its second chapter with the verse's words, said there of "the second soul in Israel."

Where the teaching goes

He opens with the words "And it was at the end of two years" (Bereishit, Genesis, 41:1) and turns at once to what the Torah was given for. He reads the verse itself further on.

Sources

Share on WhatsApp
Monday, December 7 · Day 2 of 7

Caught by the Garment

The Sages say one sin drags another after it. The Me'or Einayim (Rabbi Menachem Nachum of Chernobyl) explains what the first sin leaves behind, and what takes hold of it.

2 minute read
Think first

The Mishnah (the first written code of the Oral Torah) says: "A mitzvah (commandment) drags a mitzvah, and a sin drags a sin." A sin is over once it is done. What is left of it to drag the next one in?

Today's teaching

From a mitzvah, the Me'or Einayim says, a garment is made for a person. He calls it by a name from the Zohar (the classic of the Torah's hidden teachings): the robe that the souls of the righteous wear in the next world. From a sin, Heaven forbid, soiled garments are made. So a sin drags a sin: the yetzer hara (the evil inclination) takes hold of him by that garment and leads him to another. His example is Yosef (Joseph). The Sages say that Yosef, seeing himself a man of rank, began curling his hair. When his master's wife "caught him by his garment," this, he says, was the garment she had hold of. Yosef reflected that this was what let her catch him. "He left his garment in her hand and fled": he attached himself to Hashem (God) and took that garment off.

Read it in his wordsThe Me'or Einayim in Hebrew, with our English
ומזה הלבוש שהוא בגדים צואים אוחזו היצר הרע בלבושו ומוליכו לעשות עוד עבירה
"And from this garment, the soiled garments, the yetzer hara [the evil inclination] takes hold of him by his garment and leads him to do another sin."
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 2Open the source
Take it to work

The second wrong is pulled in by the first

You told your manager the slide deck was "basically done." The deck was a title slide. The title was "Deck." That was not true, and saying it was forbidden, but it bought a day. The next day he asked for it, and you heard yourself say the file would not open. By the third day you were keeping notes, so the fourth day's answer would match.

The Me'or Einayim says a sin leaves a soiled garment on a person. The yetzer hara takes hold of him by it and leads him to the next sin. And a Torah scholar who has sinned, he says, reflects at once, regrets it, and takes the garment off.

In our words: a slide deck is nothing like what Yosef faced in that house. We borrow only the garment. The first sentence was not over when you said it. It became something you were wearing, and the next day's was pulled in by the sleeve. A better excuse on the third day would only be more of the same garment. The scholar he describes regrets it at once and takes the thing off. The title slide, at least, was accurate.

Today's move

Think of one small wrong you keep explaining to yourself. Stop explaining, regret it, and put right the part you can today.

Send to a friend

Ask yourself, or your study partnerWhat did my last wrong leave behind that could pull the next one in?

Go deeperMore of the teaching, and every source

A garment from each deed

כי מהמצוה נעשה לבוש והוא חלוקא דרבנן ומן העבירה ח״ו נעשה בגדים צואים ולזה עבירה גוררת עבירה
"…for from a mitzvah a garment is made, and it is the chaluka d'rabbanan [the robe of the Rabbis]; and from a sin, Heaven forbid, soiled garments are made. And so a sin drags a sin."
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 2Open the source

He starts from a verse: "At all times let your garments be white" (Kohelet, Ecclesiastes, 9:8). Chaluka d'rabbanan, "the robe of the Rabbis," is a name used in the Zohar (the classic of Kabbalah, the hidden teachings of the Torah) for the garment in which the souls of the righteous are clothed in the next world (Zohar on the Torah portion Noach, 1:66a). "Soiled garments" are words of the prophet Zechariah (3:3-4): he sees Yehoshua the High Priest dressed in soiled garments, and hears, "Take the soiled garments off him… See, I have removed your sin from you." The saying about a mitzvah and a sin is Ben Azzai's, in Pirkei Avot (Ethics of the Fathers) 4:2.

A soul that sins

כי הכתוב מתמיה (ויקרא ה׳, א׳) ונפש כי תחטא כי מהראוי הוא לנפש הקדוש להשתוקק אל עבודת השם ולא לעשות עבירה חלילה רק שאין אדם חוטא עד שנכנס בו רוח שטות
"…for the verse is astonished (Vayikra [Leviticus] 5:1): 'And a soul, when it sins.' For it is fitting for the holy soul to long for the service of Hashem, and not to do a sin, Heaven forbid. Only, a person does not sin until a spirit of folly has entered him."
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 2Open the source

The Zohar on the Torah portion Vayikra reads the verse the same way: the Torah and the Holy One, blessed be He, wonder at it and say, "a soul, when it sins?" "A person does not sin unless a spirit of folly has entered him" is the saying of Reish Lakish in the Gemara (the Talmud, Sotah 3a).

Yosef and the garment

לכן ביוסף הצדיק כתיב ותתפשהו בבגדו כי היה מסלסל בשערו מחמת שראה עצמו שנעשה שררה ואחזתו בלבוש הזה והיה מתבונן בזה שמחמת זה היה ביכולת בידה לתפשו ויעזוב בגדו בידה וינס ויצא החוצה ודבק עצמו בהשם ופשט הלבוש הנ״ל
"So of Yosef the tzaddik [the righteous] it is written, 'She caught him by his garment': for he had been curling his hair, because he saw himself made [a man of] rank, and she took hold of him by this garment. And he reflected on this, that because of it she had been able to catch him. 'And he left his garment in her hand and fled and went outside': he attached himself to Hashem and took off that garment."
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 2Open the source

The verse is Bereishit (Genesis) 39:12. That Yosef curled his hair is in Rashi, the classic commentator, on Bereishit 39:6: once he saw himself a ruler, he began to eat and drink and curl his hair, and the Holy One said, "Your father is mourning, and you curl your hair?" The Midrash Tanchuma (a collection of the Sages' readings of the Torah) tells it in nearly the same words.

A scholar who has sinned

כי תלמיד חכם שעבר ביום אל תהרהר כו׳ כי אדם אין צדיק בארץ גו׳ (קהלת ז׳, כ׳) רק שהוא מתבונן תיכף ומחרט ופושט הלבוש
"…for 'a Torah scholar who sinned by day, do not think ill of him,' and so on. For 'there is no righteous person on earth,' and so on (Kohelet 7:20). Only, he reflects at once, and regrets, and takes off the garment…"
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 2Open the source

His next words end: "…and drag another sin to him." In the Gemara (Berachot 19a) the teaching is from the school of Rabbi Yishmael, and it reads: if you saw a Torah scholar sin at night, do not think ill of him by day; perhaps he has repented. The Gemara asks: only perhaps? And it answers: rather, he has certainly repented. The Gemara adds that this is said of matters that concern himself. In a matter of money, it says, not until he has returned it to its owner. The verse in Kohelet ends: "…who does good and does not sin."

And a mitzvah

וכמו כן מצוה גוררת מצוה שנעשה חלוקא דרבנן
"And in the same way a mitzvah drags a mitzvah, for a chaluka d'rabbanan is made."
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 2Open the source

Sources

Share on WhatsApp
Tuesday, December 8 · Day 3 of 7

A Person Is a Wick

A lamp needs a wick, oil and a flame. In the reading of the Me'or Einayim (Rabbi Menachem Nachum of Chernobyl) the wick is a person. He speaks of wicks that are not lit on Shabbat, because the flame does not hold on them.

2 minute read
Think first

A verse says: "At all times let your garments be white, and let oil not be lacking on your head." If the garments are a person's mitzvot (commandments), what might the oil be?

Today's teaching

Garments, in his reading of the verse, are mitzvot, and oil is wisdom. A person can be "full of mitzvot like a pomegranate" and still be without da'at (knowledge). To draw wisdom onto a person, he says, Hashem (God) gave the mitzvah of the Chanukah lamp (Chanukah is the eight-day festival of lights). As a lamp's wick is filled with oil and lit, so a person is a wick: the oil is the wisdom Hashem fills him with, and He lights him. Some wicks are poor: they are not lit on Shabbat, he says, because the light does not take hold on them. At the time of this mitzvah Hashem lowers Himself, as it were, to the person and makes the light take hold.

Read it in his wordsThe Me'or Einayim in Hebrew, with our English
כי כמו בנר נותנין לתוכו פתילה וממלאין אותה בשמן ומדליקו כמו כן האדם הוא פתילה ושמן הוא החכמה שהשם ממלא בו ומדליקו להיות מאיר במעשיו ובעבודתו את השם
"…for as with a lamp, one puts a wick in it and fills it with oil and lights it, so too a person is a wick, and the oil is the wisdom with which Hashem fills him; and He lights him, to give light by his deeds and by his service of Hashem."
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 2Open the source
Take it to work

When you do everything and nothing catches

At the weekly shiur (Torah class) a man closes his eyes when the rabbi makes a good point. You do not. You tried once; you lost your place and nearly your coffee. You come every week, you stand when people stand, and as far as you can tell, nothing has caught.

The Me'or Einayim speaks of poor wicks: people who are not lit on Shabbat, because the light does not take hold on them. This page does not say who these people are. For them too, he says, there is a time: each year, when the mitzvah of the Chanukah lamp comes, Hashem lowers Himself, as it were, to the person and makes the light take hold.

In our words: he is speaking of the time of the Chanukah lamp, and a weekly shiur is not that. We take only who does the lighting. In his picture the wick does not light itself. It is filled, and it is lit. In his reading of the verse, the person's part is the garments, the mitzvot. You came. The coffee survived.

Today's move

Choose one mitzvah you will do today anyway. Before it, ask Hashem, in one line of your own, for the understanding that goes with it.

Send to a friend

Ask yourself, or your study partnerWhere do I do everything right and still feel nothing has caught?

Go deeperMore of the teaching, and every source

Garments and oil

וזהו בכל עת יהיו בגדיך, היינו הלבושים שלך, לבנים, שתתלבש בלבושים נאים של מצות ולא מלוכלכים חלילה, ושמן על ראשך לא יחסר כי שמן מורה אל חכמה כי שמן זית מחכים ועל ידי שלבושים שלך יהיו נאים השם ימשיך עליך חכמה ודעת
"And this is 'At all times let your garments [begadecha],' that is, your levushim [garments], 'be white': that you dress in fine garments of mitzvot, and not in dirty ones, Heaven forbid. 'And oil on your head shall not be lacking': for oil points to wisdom, since olive oil makes wise. And through your garments being fine, Hashem will draw wisdom and da'at upon you…"
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 2Open the source

The verse is Kohelet (Ecclesiastes) 9:8, which reads "let oil not be lacking"; the text of the Me'or Einayim on Sefaria (an online library of Jewish texts) has "shall not be lacking" here. In the Gemara (the Talmud) Rabbi Yochanan ties olive oil to wisdom: the people of Tekoa were used to olive oil, and so wisdom was found among them (Menachot 85b); and olive oil brings back learning that was forgotten (Horayot 13b). The verse the Me'or Einayim brings next is "For Hashem gives wisdom; from His mouth are knowledge and understanding" (Mishlei, Proverbs, 2:6).

Full like a pomegranate

כי הגם שאדם עושה מצוות כי רקנים שבך מלאים מצוות כרימון, רק שהם בלא דעת ותבונה להמשיך על האדם חכמה ודעת. לזה נתן לנו השם מצות הדלקת נר חנוכה
"For although a person does mitzvot (for 'the empty ones among you are full of mitzvot like a pomegranate'), still they are without the da'at and understanding to draw wisdom and da'at upon a person. For this Hashem gave us the mitzvah of lighting the Chanukah lamp."
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 2Open the source

"Even the empty ones among you are full of mitzvot like a pomegranate" is Reish Lakish's reading of a verse in Shir HaShirim, the Song of Songs (Eruvin 19a).

Below ten

ולכן נר חנוכה הוא למעלה מג׳ שלא תהא כארעא סמיכתא ולמטה מעשרה כי מעולם לא ירדה שכינה למטה מעשרה רק שהשם חושב מחשבות לבלתי ידח ממנו נדח היה על ידי נס שהשם כביכול מוריד למטה מעשרה ומתקרב אל האדם להשיבו ולהחזירו אליו
"And so the Chanukah lamp is above three [handbreadths], so that it is not counted as the ground itself, and below ten. For the Shechinah [the Divine Presence] never came down below ten. But Hashem 'devises plans so that no one banished remain banished from Him': it was by a miracle that Hashem, as it were, lowers [Himself] below ten and draws near to a person, to turn him and bring him back to Him."
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 2Open the source

The Shulchan Aruch (the standard code of Jewish law), Orach Chaim 671:6, rules that the Chanukah lamp is placed above three handbreadths, and that it is a mitzvah to place it below ten. "Below ten" comes from a statement of Ravina in the Gemara (Shabbat 21b): it is a mitzvah to place it "within ten." Ravina learns this from another law. The Gemara asks whether that law really proves it, and leaves the question there. The Shulchan Aruch rules this way. Rabbi Yosei teaches that the Shechinah never came down below. The Gemara asks from verses that say it did, and answers that it stayed above ten handbreadths (Sukkah 5a). The verse is Shmuel II (2 Samuel) 14:14.

Shabbat is high

רק שקשה עליו על האדם ליכנוס בתוך קדושת שבת כי רם ונשא הוא השבת כי הוא שמא דקב״ה ואיך יכול לקרב אל מקום גבוה ורם כזה אך בחנוכה כביכול השם מוריד את עצמו למטה מעשרה אל אדם לקרבו
"…only, it is hard for a person to enter into the holiness of Shabbat, for Shabbat is high and lifted up, for it is the Name of the Holy One, blessed be He. How can he come close to a place so high and lifted up? But on Chanukah, as it were, Hashem lowers Himself below ten, to a person, to bring him close."
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 2Open the source

"The Name of the Holy One" is what the Zohar (the classic of Kabbalah, the hidden teachings of the Torah) calls Shabbat, on the Torah portion Yitro. Just before this he calls Shabbat "a good gift" from Hashem's treasure house, given to bring a person close to his Creator. The words are from the Gemara (Shabbat 10b): "I have a good gift in My treasure house, and Shabbat is its name."

Wicks that are not lit on Shabbat

The Sages ruled out certain wicks and oils for the Shabbat lamp. Rabbah gives the reasons: on those wicks the flame flickers, and those oils are not drawn up the wick. The Gemara (Shabbat 21a-b) then brings three opinions about using them for the Chanukah lamp. Rav Huna: they may not be used. Rav Chisda: on weekdays they may, on Shabbat they may not. Rabbi Zeira in the name of Rav Matnah, and some say in the name of Rav: they may be used on Chanukah, on weekdays and on Shabbat. The Shulchan Aruch (Orach Chaim 673:1) rules that all oils and wicks are fit for the Chanukah lamp, even those on which the light does not hold well. The Me'or Einayim quotes the teaching in that last form, and reads the wicks as people.

והנה הפתילות הם בני אדם שאין נדלקין בשבת שהאור אין נאחז בו מחמת שהפתילות לא טובים
"Now the wicks are people who are not lit on Shabbat: the light does not take hold in him, because the wicks are not good…"
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 2Open the source

This page does not say who these people are.

כי השם כביכול בעצמו מוריד את עצמו אל האדם ומאחיז בו את האור להדליקו ולשוב ולחזור אל השם ולעובדו בהתלהבות ובשכל גדול
"…for Hashem, as it were, Himself lowers Himself to the person and makes the light take hold in him, to light him, to turn and come back to Hashem, and to serve Him with fervor and with great understanding."
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 2Open the source
וזה נעשה בכל שנה בבוא הזמן של מצות נר חנוכה
"And this is done every year, when the time of the mitzvah of the Chanukah lamp comes."
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 2Open the source

Why Chanukah is in this chapter

In most years Parshat Miketz (the Torah portion of Miketz) is read on the Shabbat of Chanukah. The Me'or Einayim says there is a reason it is read then (Miketz 4), and much of his chapter on the parsha is about Chanukah. This day brings one piece of it.

Sources

Share on WhatsApp
Wednesday, December 9 · Day 4 of 7

At the End of the Days of Sleep

Parshat Miketz (the Torah portion of Miketz) opens: "And it was at the end of two years, and Pharaoh was dreaming." The Me'or Einayim (Rabbi Menachem Nachum of Chernobyl) hears another word inside "two years": sleep.

2 minute read
Think first

"Two years" in Hebrew is shenatayim. Sleep is sheinah. The verse says, "And it was at the end of shenatayim, and Pharaoh was dreaming." If the verse is also about a person, what would "the end of the sleep" be?

Today's teaching

Shenatayim, "two years," he reads as sheinah, sleep. Sleep, he says, comes when the mind departs from a person, out of preoccupation. A person may do mitzvot (commandments) and learn Torah, and without mind he is "like one asleep." So "at the end of two years" is the close of the days of sleep: a person wakes from what he calls "the sleep of time," and learns with his mind. Torah learned without mind, he has just said, has no power to bring a miracle into the open. Torah learned with the mind can. So he reads on: Pharaoh (the king of Egypt), he brings from "the writings," is a word for revelation. Dreaming, cholem, he reads as a word for health: the revelation of miracles grows strong. And the river Pharaoh stands by, he says, is the Torah.

Read it in his wordsThe Me'or Einayim in Hebrew, with our English
וזהו ויהי מקץ שנתים ימים שנתים לשון שינה ויהי מסוף כלות ימי השינה שנתעורר האדם משינת הזמן
"And this is 'And it was at the end of two years [shenatayim] of days': shenatayim is a word for sheinah [sleep]. 'And it was,' at the close of the days of sleep, when a person has woken from the sleep of time…"
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 3Open the source
Take it to work

A whole morning can be done by someone who is not there

By mid-morning you have davened (prayed), answered fourteen emails and sat through a team meeting. You know this from the evidence: the emails say "Sent," and your name is in the meeting notes next to the word "agreed." You do not remember what you agreed to. Somewhere in the Amidah (the standing prayer) you chose a seat on a flight.

The Me'or Einayim says a person can do mitzvot and learn Torah, and without mind be "like one asleep."

In our words: he is speaking of Torah and mitzvot done without the mind. His words name no prayer and no meeting. Prayer is a mitzvah, so we take the Amidah to come under his words, and we borrow his word for the rest of the morning too. Every word was said. The emails were polite. It was all done by someone who had stepped out. How a person wakes for good, this page does not know. Once is easier: the next blessing, said by the one saying it. The seat was 14C.

Today's move

Pick one blessing you say without thinking. If you say none, pick one to say today. Say it with your mind on it, from its first word to its last.

Send to a friend

Ask yourself, or your study partnerWhich part of my day do I do asleep?

Go deeperMore of the teaching, and every source

What sleep is

Before this he brings a verse: "How long, lazy one, will you lie there? When will you rise from your sleep?" (Mishlei, Proverbs, 6:9). And he explains:

כי שינה הוא מחמת הסתלקות המוחין מן האדם
"…for sleep comes from the departure of the mochin [the powers of the mind] from a person…"
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 2Open the source

He goes on to give the cause, in a word for being preoccupied, taken up with things. And then:

ואדם הגם שעושה מצוות ולומד תורה בלא מוח הוא כמו ישן דמי
"…and a person, though he does mitzvot and learns Torah, without mind is like one asleep."
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 2Open the source

And a miracle

In the lines before this he has been speaking of miracles that are hidden and miracles that are revealed. He closes the passage with them:

ואז אין כח בתורתו לעשות נס נגלה רק אחר שלומד במוח ושכל יכול לגרום שיתגלה נס
"…and then his Torah has no power to bring about a revealed miracle. Only after he learns with mind and understanding can he cause a miracle to be revealed."
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 2Open the source

That sentence is his. The card above takes from this teaching only the picture of sleep. Whether a prayer said without attention must be said again is a matter of halachah (Jewish law), and it is not this page's to say.

Pharaoh

ואיתא בכתבים כי פרעה לשון התגלות יום הולדת את פרעה שנולד ההתגלות
"And it says in the writings that Pharaoh is a word for revelation. 'The day of Pharaoh's birth': that the revelation was born."
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 2Open the source

His words here are only "the writings." Later in this chapter (paragraph 11), on another matter, he names "the writings of the Arizal," Rabbi Yitzchak Luria of Tzfat, a teacher of Kabbalah (the hidden teachings of the Torah). "The day of Pharaoh's birth" is from Bereishit (Genesis) 40:20. Pharaoh in Hebrew is Par'oh. Its first letters, p-r-a, are a Hebrew root with the sense of uncovering: Rashi, the classic commentator, explains the word parua (Shemot, Exodus, 32:25) as "uncovered." The Zohar (the classic of Kabbalah), on the Torah portion Vayigash, reads "the house of Pharaoh" as the house from which all the lights are uncovered and revealed.

The dream and the river

ופרעה הוא התגלות חולם הוא לשון בריאות הדר חלים, שנתחזק התגלות הנסים והנה עומד על היאור היא התורה
"And Pharaoh is revelation. 'Dreaming' [cholem] is a word for health, as in hadar chalim [it is healthy again]: the revelation of the miracles grew strong. 'And behold, he stands by the river': that is the Torah."
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 3Open the source

The Sages also tie a dream to health. Among six things that are a good sign for a sick person, the Gemara (the Talmud, Berachot 57b) counts a dream, from the verse "You restore me to health [vatachalimeni] and make me live" (Yeshayahu, Isaiah, 38:16). Hadar chalim is Aramaic for "it heals again"; Rashi uses the words in his commentary on the Gemara (Chullin 45a).

Sources

Share on WhatsApp
Thursday, December 10 · Day 5 of 7

Hatred Begins With "That Honor Was Mine"

In the dream of Pharaoh, king of Egypt, seven good cows graze in a meadow. The Me'or Einayim (Rabbi Menachem Nachum of Chernobyl) reads the cows as seven traits in a person, and the meadow as brotherhood.

2 minute read
Think first

In the dream, seven cows graze in the achu, the meadow. The Me'or Einayim reads achu as brotherhood. Why might cows be his picture for people who do not hate each other?

Today's teaching

The seven good cows, he says, are seven traits turned toward Hashem (God): to love Him, to fear Him, to glorify Him, to defeat the yetzer hara (the evil inclination), to thank Him, to be bound to all these, and to make Him king. They are called cows because a person has to make himself "like a beast": of himself, he says, a person has nothing, and whatever good is in him is from Hashem. The cows graze in the achu, which he reads as brotherhood. A person hates his fellow, he says, out of gadlut (holding himself great): it seems to him that the honor is due to him, and he envies. One who makes himself like a beast loves the whole world.

Read it in his wordsThe Me'or Einayim in Hebrew, with our English
כי מה שאדם שונא את חבירו הוא מחמת גדלות ודומה לו שלו ראוי הכבוד והגדולה ומקנא לחבירו אבל אם משים עצמו כבהמה אז הוא אוהב את כל העולם ואין לו שום שנאה על חבירו
"…for when a person hates his fellow, it is out of gadlut [holding himself great]: it seems to him that the honor and the greatness are due to him, and he envies his fellow. But if he makes himself like a beast, then he loves the whole world, and has no hatred at all for his fellow."
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 3Open the source
Take it to work

When a colleague is praised, catch your first thought

The announcement came in the team channel, with a trophy emoji: a colleague who started after you will lead the new account. A minute later you had typed "Congrats!!" with one more exclamation point than you felt. Within twenty minutes you had a list of his faults. It included his laugh. You had never minded the laugh before the announcement.

The Me'or Einayim says where hatred of a fellow comes from: gadlut. It seems to a person that the honor was due to him, and he envies.

In our words: this page is not ruling on who should have got the account. He says this of hatred of a fellow, with no exception. The line here is ours: we apply his words only to the hatred that grows out of envy, when honor goes to someone else, and not to a person who has really been hurt by someone. His order of events: first "that was mine," then the envy, and only then the laugh. The laugh did nothing. It is the same laugh it was the minute before.

Today's move

The next time a colleague is praised, catch your first thought. If it is "that should have been me," say so to yourself, then congratulate them in one plain sentence.

Send to a friend

Ask yourself, or your study partnerWhose success bothered me lately, and what did I think was owed to me?

Go deeperMore of the teaching, and every source

Seven traits

והנה שבעה מדות הם אהבה לאהוב את השם ויראה לירא מלפניו ותפארת לפאר את השם נצח לנצח את היצר הרע לעולם ירגיז אדם יצר טוב על יצר הרע והוד להודות את השם ויסוד שיהא מקושר אל כל המדות הנ״ל ומלכות הוא ליתן ממשלה ושררות להשם להמליכו על כל העולם
"And the seven traits are: love, to love Hashem; and fear, to be in fear before Him; and glory [tiferet], to glorify Hashem; victory [netzach], to defeat the yetzer hara [the evil inclination], 'a person should always stir up the good inclination against the evil inclination'; and hod [splendor], to thank [lehodot] Hashem; and foundation [yesod], that he be bound to all these traits; and kingship [malchut], which is to give rule and authority to Hashem, to make Him king over all the world."
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 3Open the source

In Kabbalah (the hidden teachings of the Torah) these are names of seven of the ten sefirot (the ten divine attributes that Kabbalah describes); the first two are usually called chesed, kindness, and gevurah, strength. Here he speaks of them as traits in a person. "A person should always stir up the good inclination against the evil inclination" is taught in the name of Reish Lakish in the Gemara (the Talmud, Berachot 5a). His word for thanking, lehodot, also means to praise and to acknowledge.

Like a beast

כי האדם מגרמיה לית ליה כלום ומה שיש בו איזה דבר טוב ומעלה הוא מן השם
"…for a person, of himself, has nothing at all; and whatever good thing and virtue there is in him is from Hashem."
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 3Open the source
לכן נקראו המדות בשם פרות שצריך האדם להשים עצמו כבהמה
"So the traits are called cows, for a person needs to make himself like a beast."
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 3Open the source

He starts from the verse "Man and beast You save, Hashem" (Tehillim, Psalms, 36:7). In the Gemara (Chullin 5b) Rav Yehudah says in the name of Rav: these are people who are sharp in mind and make themselves like a beast. Rashi, the classic commentator, explains there: lowly of spirit. For the good in a person being from Hashem, the Me'or Einayim brings "For Hashem gives wisdom" (Mishlei, Proverbs, 2:6).

The meadow

The verse is Bereishit (Genesis) 41:2: the cows "grazed in the achu." Rashi explains achu as a marsh, and English translations mostly say "reed grass" or "marsh." This page says "meadow" to keep it simple. Targum Onkelos, the classic Aramaic translation of the Torah, has be'achavah here, and the Me'or Einayim quotes the word:

ותרעינה באחו ומתרגם באחווא
"'And they grazed in the achu,' and the Targum renders it be'achavah…"
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 3Open the source

From the Targum's word he goes straight on to hatred and love between people. "Brotherhood" is the reading of the Midrash (the Sages' readings of the verses), which this page uses. Bereishit Rabbah 89:4 reads the word that way: when the years are good, people become brothers to one another; "they grazed in the achu": love and brotherhood in the world. Rashi brings a reading like it on the words "fair to look at": in years of plenty people look good in one another's eyes, and no one begrudges his fellow.

Hatred

The Torah's words are "Do not hate your brother in your heart" (Vayikra, Leviticus, 19:17). What counts as that hatred is a matter of halachah (Jewish law), and it is not this page's to say. The card describes a bad half hour and where, in his account, such a thing begins.

Sources

Share on WhatsApp
Friday, December 11 · Day 6 of 7

The Same Seven Traits, Turned Toward Yourself

In Pharaoh's dream, seven other cows come up after the seven good ones and eat them. The Me'or Einayim (Rabbi Menachem Nachum of Chernobyl) reads them as the same seven traits, turned by the yetzer hara (the evil inclination).

2 minute read
Think first

A trait like love can be turned toward Hashem (God). What does it look like turned toward yourself?

Today's teaching

The yetzer hara, he says, comes to make a person sin through the same seven traits: to love money and other pleasures; to fear punishment; to glorify himself; to defeat his enemy; to give the thanks to himself; to be bound up in all these; and to be the ruler himself. Then, in his wording, the cows are swallowed. He goes straight on, and where the sentence stands he is still speaking of the person the yetzer hara has brought to sin through the seven: with even all the mitzvot (commandments) such a person does, he gives strength to the kelipah (the "husk": the name, in the Torah's hidden teachings, for the side that is not holiness), may the Merciful One save us, and the kelipah swallows the Torah and the mitzvot. And so, he says, teshuvah (returning to Hashem) brings the merits he did out from under its hand.

Read it in his wordsThe Me'or Einayim in Hebrew, with our English
ולכן בעשות האדם תשובה זדונות נעשין זכיות היינו שהזכיות שעשה מוציא אותם מתחת יד הקליפה
"And so, when a person does teshuvah, 'intentional sins become merits': that is, the merits that he did, he brings them out from under the hand of the kelipah."
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 4Open the source
Take it to work

Ask who a good deed was for

You gave the dvar Torah (a short Torah talk) at the office lunch-and-learn, and it went well. You know because you watched the room, and afterward stood by the door, where people leaving had to say something.

Of a person brought to sin in all seven traits, the Me'or Einayim says a hard thing: with even all the mitzvot he does, he gives strength to the kelipah. In his next line he gives the way back: teshuvah brings "the merits he did" out again.

In our words: his sentence is about a person brought to sin in all seven traits, and about "all the mitzvot" that person does. It is not about one talk, and this page does not say it is about you. Nobody in the room could tell who the talk was for. You can ask. None of this is a reason to give fewer divrei Torah, or to wait for clean motives. And in the Gemara (the Talmud, Pesachim 50b) Rav Yehudah says in the name of Rav: a person should always occupy himself with Torah and mitzvot even "not for their own sake," for some reason other than the mitzvah itself, because from that he comes to do them for their own sake.

Today's move

Think of one good thing you did lately. Ask yourself, honestly, who it was for. Then do the next good thing anyway.

Send to a friend

Ask yourself, or your study partnerWhich of my strengths do I mostly use for myself?

Go deeperMore of the teaching, and every source

The seven, in the hands of the yetzer hara

כי היצר הרע בא להחטיאו בשבעה המדות לאהוב חמדת ממון ושארי תענוגים ולירא את העונש ולהתפאר בעצמו ולנצח את שונאו ולהודות את עצמו ויהא מקושר בכל דבר הנ״ל ולהשתרר הוא בעצמו
"…for the yetzer hara [the evil inclination] comes to make him sin in the seven traits: to love the craving for money and other pleasures; and to fear punishment; and to glorify himself; and to defeat his enemy; and to give the thanks to himself; and to be bound up in every one of these; and to be the ruler himself."
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 4Open the source

Swallowed

ותבלענה הפרות גו׳ כי גם כל המצוות שאדם עושה הוא נותן כח בקליפה רחמנא ליצלן וזהו ותבלענה כי הקליפה בולע
"'And the cows swallowed,' and so on: for with even all the mitzvot that a person does, he gives strength to the kelipah, may the Merciful One save us. And this is 'and they swallowed': for the kelipah swallows…"
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 4Open the source

What it swallows, he goes on, is the Torah and the mitzvot. His words here are "the mitzvot that a person does." This page reads the sentence of the person in the list just before it. In the Torah the thin cows "ate" the fat ones (Bereishit, Genesis, 41:4); "swallowed" is the word for the thin ears of grain in the second dream (41:7). In the text of the Me'or Einayim on Sefaria (an online library of Jewish texts), the cows are cited with "swallowed." Kelipah means a husk or a shell. In Kabbalah (the Torah's hidden teachings) it is the name for the side that is not holiness, which covers holiness the way a shell covers a fruit.

It could not be known

When Pharaoh, the king of Egypt, retells the dream to Yosef (Joseph), he adds: "They came inside them, and it could not be known that they had come inside them, and their appearance was as bad as at the start" (Bereishit 41:21). The Me'or Einayim quotes the middle words, "it could not be known that they had come inside them," and goes straight on to teshuvah.

Teshuvah

His words on teshuvah are in "Read it in his words," above. The saying he quotes there is Reish Lakish's in the Gemara (the Talmud, Yoma 86b), where the wording is that intentional sins "become for him like merits." The Gemara sets it beside another saying of his, that they become for him like unintended ones, and answers: "merits" is said of teshuvah out of love, and "unintended ones" of teshuvah out of fear. The Me'or Einayim gives the saying a reading of his own. The Mishnah (the first written code of the Oral Torah, Yoma 8:9) sets a limit: one who says, "I will sin and then return, I will sin and then return," is not given the chance to do teshuvah.

And one whose motives are mixed

This is not from the Me'or Einayim's teaching. In the Gemara (Pesachim 50b) Rav Yehudah says in the name of Rav: a person should always occupy himself with Torah and mitzvot even not for their own sake, because out of doing them not for their own sake he comes to do them for their own sake. The Gemara also records a hard saying that Rava used to repeat (Berachot 17a). He speaks of a person who learns Torah and then scorns his father, his mother and his teacher, and ends: one who does it not for its own sake, it would have been better for him had he not been created. Tosafot on that page (medieval commentators printed beside the Gemara) explain that the two do not clash: Rava speaks of one who learns only to provoke his fellows, and Rav of one who learns so that people will honor him. This page does not place anyone's case on either side.

The other fear

"To fear punishment" is on his list of what the yetzer hara does with the trait of fear. In the last paragraph of the chapter he gives the pairs again, and there the wording is "outer fear."

ויש כנגדו אהבת תענוגים ויראה חיצונית והתפארות את עצמו לנצח את חבירו ולהודות את אשר חפץ והתקשרות בכל המדות הנ״ל
"And over against it there is love of pleasures, and outer fear, and glorifying oneself, to defeat one's fellow, and to thank whatever one desires, and being bound to all these traits."
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 11

Pharaoh woke

ויקץ פרעה והנה חלום כשמקיץ אדם משינת הזמן
"'And Pharaoh woke, and behold, a dream': when a person wakes from the sleep of time…"
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 4Open the source

"The sleep of time" is his phrase from the start of this reading of the dream, where "two years," shenatayim, is read as sheinah, sleep. He explains sleep just before that, at the end of the second paragraph: a person who does mitzvot and learns Torah without his mind in it "is like one asleep."

How the paragraph closes

He closes this paragraph by saying that a person should have no aim but Hashem alone, "not for this world and not for the world to come." This page does not cover that part.

Sources

Share on WhatsApp
Shabbat, December 12 · Day 7 of 7

As If All Your Work Is Done

The Mishnah (the first written code of the Oral Torah) counts the kinds of work forbidden on Shabbat as "forty less one." The Me'or Einayim (Rabbi Menachem Nachum of Chernobyl) explains why it does not say thirty-nine.

For the Shabbat table. Print it on Friday.

2 minute read
Think first

Why would the Mishnah say "forty less one" and not thirty-nine? What might "lacking one" be telling us about work?

Today's teaching

On Shabbat, the Me'or Einayim says, it has to be as if a person's work is done. One who works does so because he lacks something. Shabbat, he says in the words of the Zohar (the classic of the Torah's hidden teachings), is the Name of the Holy One, blessed be He, as it were whole on every side: it lacks nothing and needs no work. So, he says, the thirty-nine are called "kinds of work" only for a person who is "lacking one": one who, Heaven forbid, does not have Shabbat whole. He goes on to say what the "one" is, in a few lines about two Shabbatot. This page does not cover them. In a separate short piece he brings the same thought to a verse. On "He rested and was refreshed," vayinafash, Reish Lakish says in the Gemara (the Talmud): once he has rested, vai, woe, the soul is lost. He says it of the added soul that leaves a person when Shabbat ends. The Me'or Einayim reads Reish Lakish's words differently: on Shabbat a person lacks nothing, and what is lost is the "woe" he had before it.

Read it in his wordsThe Me'or Einayim in Hebrew, with our English
כי הנה צריך להיות בשבת כאילו מלאכתו עשויה
"…for on Shabbat it has to be as if his work is done…"
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 9Open the source
Take it to the Shabbat table

For one meal, sit as if the week were finished

You sit down at the Shabbat table, and the week sits down with you. It has brought a meeting that went badly, an email you sent too fast, and a remark you would now put differently. The soup arrives. You nod at the soup. You are, in fact, replaying the remark.

The Me'or Einayim says that on Shabbat it has to be as if a person's work is done. Work, he says, comes from a lack, and Shabbat lacks nothing.

In our words: the week is real. His words are "as if." The work is not finished; for this one day a person sits as if it were. This card is about the small unfinished things. If you are carrying something heavy this Shabbat, this card is not about you, and nothing on this page measures your Shabbat. Put the week down by the salt. The person on your left is halfway through a story about a goat.

This Shabbat

At one meal this Shabbat, when the week starts up in your head, answer it with two words, "as if," and turn back to the person talking.

Send to a friend

Ask yourself, or your study partnerWhat would I notice at this table if the week were really behind me?

Look back at your week

Which move actually stuck?

Pick the one you will keep doing. Moves you marked "I did it" have a check.

Go deeperMore of the teaching, and every source

Forty less one

אבות מלאכות ארבעים חסר אחת ולא אמרו ל״ט מלאכות
"'The main kinds of work are forty less one,' and they did not say 'thirty-nine kinds of work'…"
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 9Open the source

The Mishnah is Shabbat 7:2. It goes on to list them, from sowing and plowing to carrying from one domain to another.

As if it were done

The teaching is in the Mechilta, an early Midrash (the Sages' readings of the verses) on Shemot (Exodus), on the verse "Six days you shall work and do all your work" (Shemot 20:9): can a person do all his work in six days? Rather, rest as if all your work were done. Rashi, the classic commentator, brings it on that verse: when Shabbat comes, let it be in your eyes as if all your work is done, so that you do not think about work.

The Name, the King's house and the queen

כי העושה מלאכה הוא מחמת שהוא חסר מאותה מלאכה ועושה זה המלאכה להשלים חסרונו הוא הכלי שעושה שהיה צריך לה ושבת הוא שמא דקב״ה כביכול שלים מכל סטרוי ואין צריך לשום מלאכה שאינו חסר כלום
"For one who does work does it because he is lacking [what] that work [gives], and he does the work to fill what he lacks: it is the vessel he makes, which he needed. And Shabbat is the Name of the Holy One, blessed be He, as it were whole on every side, and needs no work, for there is nothing lacking."
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 9Open the source
ועוד כלום חסר בבית המלך ושבת מלכתא היא נמצא לא נקראו מלאכות כי אם כשהוא חסר אחת היינו באם ח״ו אין לו שבת בשלימות וחסר אחת אז המה מלאכות
"And further: 'Is anything lacking in the King's house?' And Shabbat is a queen. So they are called kinds of work only when one is 'lacking one': that is, if, Heaven forbid, he does not have Shabbat in its wholeness, and is lacking one, then they are kinds of work."
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 9Open the source

"What is Shabbat? The Name of the Holy One, blessed be He, the Name that is whole on every side" is from the Zohar, in its section on the Torah portion Yitro (2:88b). "Is anything lacking in the King's house?" is from a parable of Rabban Yochanan ben Zakkai in the Gemara (Shabbat 153a), about a king who invited his servants to a feast and set no hour for it. Rabbi Chanina would say on the eve of Shabbat, "Come, let us go out to greet Shabbat the queen" (Shabbat 119a). The Me'or Einayim goes on, with the words "that is," to say what the "one" is: one of two Shabbatot. He ties it to the saying in the Gemara (Shabbat 118b) that if Israel kept two Shabbatot properly they would be redeemed at once; he quotes it without "properly." This page does not cover those lines, and they are printed twice in the text on Sefaria (an online library of Jewish texts).

Woe, the soul is lost

שבת וינפש כיון ששבת וי אבדה נפש פירוש בשבת אינו חסר כלום ונאבד הוי שהיה לאדם קודם השבת
"'He rested and was refreshed [vayinafash]': once he has rested, vai avdah nefesh [woe, the soul is lost]. Meaning: on Shabbat he lacks nothing, and the 'woe' that a person had before Shabbat is lost."
Me'or Einayim, Miketz 10

The verse is Shemot 31:17. In the Gemara (Beitzah 16a) Reish Lakish says that the Holy One gives a person an added soul on the eve of Shabbat, and when Shabbat goes out it is taken from him, as it says, "He rested and was refreshed": once he has rested, woe, the soul is lost. Rashi explains there: woe for the soul that has gone. The Me'or Einayim reads the same words another way: what is lost is the woe.

Where this is in the book

On Sefaria, these lines stand among several short pieces on Shabbat in the Me'or Einayim's chapter on this parsha (Torah portion). The line about "woe" is a piece of its own, in the tenth paragraph.

Thought and talk on Shabbat

The card describes a table. It does not rule on what may be thought or said at one. The Shulchan Aruch (the standard code of Jewish law), Orach Chaim 306:8, writes: "Thinking about one's affairs is permitted. And all the same, for the sake of the delight of Shabbat, it is a mitzvah (commandment) not to think about them at all, and let it be in his eyes as if all his work is done." The Mishnah Berurah (a later commentary on that code) adds there: all the more so if the thinking brings a troubled heart and worry, a person should be careful of it. The laws of speech on Shabbat are in Orach Chaim 307. What all this asks of you at your own table is a question for your rav (rabbi).

Sources

Share on WhatsApp

Free, Sunday to Friday

Get the daily dose by email

One short email a day with that day's teaching and a link to read it here. Friday's email includes the Shabbat dose. Unsubscribe anytime.

The Hebrew of the Me'or Einayim and of every other source is from Sefaria. The quotes are short excerpts. We do not quote everything in each paragraph, and we write the name of God with a kuf. English renderings, explanations and the "Take it to work" applications are Torah Tech originals, and any mistakes are ours.

This page is for learning. It is not a halachic ruling. For practical questions, ask your rav.

Torah Tech · torahtech.co/meor · The Opportunity Year in Tel Aviv · Learn more and apply at torahtech.co
The Opportunity Year · Tel Aviv, Israel

Learn like this for a year

Torah Tech is a beit midrash in Tel Aviv built for personal and professional growth: Torah learning at the center of every day, and internships at Israeli startups. It is the year a future Jewish leader realizes who he can become, and chooses to become it.