Read the Story as Directions
Yaakov, here called Yisrael, loved Yosef and made him a coat. The Me'or Einayim (Rabbi Menachem Nachum of Chernobyl) asks of this verse: what way does it show?
2 minute readThe word Torah, the Me'or Einayim says, comes from moreh derech, "one who shows the way." This week's parsha (Torah portion) starts with a family story: Yisrael (Yaakov) loved Yosef more than all his sons. If Torah means showing the way, what would you ask about that verse?
The Torah is eternal, the Me'or Einayim says. It is in every person and in every age, and it came before the world. But it was clothed in stories, according to the time: when the Avot (the forefathers) Avraham, Yitzchak and Yaakov lived, the Torah was clothed in their stories. Even so, he says, it has to be so in every age. It is called Torah from the words moreh derech, one who shows the way. And so, he says, we need to understand what way is shown in this verse, "Yisrael loved Yosef." He comes back to the verse only at the end. All week we follow this one teaching, a step a day.
Read it in his wordsThe Me'or Einayim in Hebrew, with our English
A story you know by heart can still show you a way
You know this story. You have known it since you were six, when it came with a coloring page: one coat, and a strong suggestion to use every crayon in the box. You used them. You got a sticker. The matter was settled, and it has stayed settled for twenty years. Each year the reading comes around to the coat, and you nod at it, the way you nod at a neighbor.
The Me'or Einayim asks the verse a question. The Torah, he says, is eternal, in every person and in every age, and the stories of the Avot are what it was clothed in when they lived. It is called Torah because it shows the way. So he asks what way this verse shows.
In our words: that is a different question from "what does it mean," which can be answered from the couch. A way is something you walk on, on a weekday. The coloring page was not wrong. There is a coat. He holds that there are directions in it too, and he takes the whole teaching to say what they are. The answer takes until Shabbat.
Read Bereishit (Genesis) 37:3 once, slowly. Before tomorrow, write down one guess: what way might this verse be showing?
Ask yourself, or your study partnerWhich story do I know so well that I have stopped asking it anything?
Go deeperMore of the teaching, and every source
The verse
The verse is Bereishit (Genesis) 37:3: "And Yisrael loved Yosef more than all his sons, for he was a son of his old age, and he made him a ketonet passim," the special coat. The Me'or Einayim quotes its first words and goes on to other things. He reads the rest of the verse in the last lines of the teaching.
Eternal, and before the world
The Gemara (the Talmud, Pesachim 54a) quotes a teaching that seven things were created before the world, and the Torah is the first on the list. It learns this from the verse "Hashem [God] made me as the beginning of His way" (Mishlei, Proverbs, 8:22).
His question
One teaching, seven days
The Me'or Einayim has one short teaching on Parshat Vayeshev. In the text on Sefaria (an online library of Jewish texts) it is five paragraphs long. This week's seven days follow it in his order. From the verse he turns to why the world was created, then to a Mishnah (a teaching from the first written code of the Oral Torah) about servants and reward, then to how a world with limits can exist, then to why the Torah has stories in it at all, then to the Exodus from Egypt. Only then does he read the verse.
Sources
- Me'or Einayim, Vayeshev 1: the Torah is eternal and clothed in stories; Torah as showing the way.
- Bereishit 37:3: "Yisrael loved Yosef."
- Pesachim 54a: the Torah was created before the world.
- Mishlei 8:22: "the beginning of His way."