Me'or Einayim, Daily Parshat Vayeshev
Torah Tech torahtech.co/meor/vayeshev
Me'or Einayim · Parshat Vayeshev
וַיֵּשֶׁב

Seven days with the Chernobyler Maggid

One short teaching a day from the Me'or Einayim ("Light of the Eyes"), the book of Rabbi Menachem Nachum of Chernobyl (1730 to 1797), known as the Chernobyler Maggid, the preacher of Chernobyl. His words, what he means, and how to take it to work. About two minutes. Want more? Every day has a "Go deeper" section with more of the teaching and every source.

His words are in the dark boxes. Take it to work is our application of his idea.

On Vayeshev the Me'or Einayim has one short teaching. This week follows it in seven steps, one a day.

Sunday, November 29 · Day 1 of 7

Read the Story as Directions

Yaakov, here called Yisrael, loved Yosef and made him a coat. The Me'or Einayim (Rabbi Menachem Nachum of Chernobyl) asks of this verse: what way does it show?

2 minute read
Think first

The word Torah, the Me'or Einayim says, comes from moreh derech, "one who shows the way." This week's parsha (Torah portion) starts with a family story: Yisrael (Yaakov) loved Yosef more than all his sons. If Torah means showing the way, what would you ask about that verse?

Today's teaching

The Torah is eternal, the Me'or Einayim says. It is in every person and in every age, and it came before the world. But it was clothed in stories, according to the time: when the Avot (the forefathers) Avraham, Yitzchak and Yaakov lived, the Torah was clothed in their stories. Even so, he says, it has to be so in every age. It is called Torah from the words moreh derech, one who shows the way. And so, he says, we need to understand what way is shown in this verse, "Yisrael loved Yosef." He comes back to the verse only at the end. All week we follow this one teaching, a step a day.

Read it in his wordsThe Me'or Einayim in Hebrew, with our English
אלא שנתלבשה בסיפורי מעשיות כפי הזמן דהיינו בעת שהיו האבות אברהם יצחק ויעקב נתלבשה התורה בסיפורי המעשיות שלהם אך מכל מקום צריך להיות כן בכל זמן ונקרא תורה מלשון מורה דרך
"…only it was clothed in stories, according to the time. That is, when the Avot [the forefathers] Avraham, Yitzchak and Yaakov lived, the Torah was clothed in their stories. But even so, it has to be so in every age, and it is called Torah from the words moreh derech [one who shows the way]."
Me'or Einayim, Vayeshev 1Open the source
Take it to work

A story you know by heart can still show you a way

You know this story. You have known it since you were six, when it came with a coloring page: one coat, and a strong suggestion to use every crayon in the box. You used them. You got a sticker. The matter was settled, and it has stayed settled for twenty years. Each year the reading comes around to the coat, and you nod at it, the way you nod at a neighbor.

The Me'or Einayim asks the verse a question. The Torah, he says, is eternal, in every person and in every age, and the stories of the Avot are what it was clothed in when they lived. It is called Torah because it shows the way. So he asks what way this verse shows.

In our words: that is a different question from "what does it mean," which can be answered from the couch. A way is something you walk on, on a weekday. The coloring page was not wrong. There is a coat. He holds that there are directions in it too, and he takes the whole teaching to say what they are. The answer takes until Shabbat.

Today's move

Read Bereishit (Genesis) 37:3 once, slowly. Before tomorrow, write down one guess: what way might this verse be showing?

Send to a friend

Ask yourself, or your study partnerWhich story do I know so well that I have stopped asking it anything?

Go deeperMore of the teaching, and every source

The verse

The verse is Bereishit (Genesis) 37:3: "And Yisrael loved Yosef more than all his sons, for he was a son of his old age, and he made him a ketonet passim," the special coat. The Me'or Einayim quotes its first words and goes on to other things. He reads the rest of the verse in the last lines of the teaching.

Eternal, and before the world

הנה נודע היות התורה נצחית בכל אדם ובכל זמן והיא קדמה לעולם
"It is known that the Torah is eternal, in every person and in every age, and that it came before the world."
Me'or Einayim, Vayeshev 1Open the source

The Gemara (the Talmud, Pesachim 54a) quotes a teaching that seven things were created before the world, and the Torah is the first on the list. It learns this from the verse "Hashem [God] made me as the beginning of His way" (Mishlei, Proverbs, 8:22).

His question

ואם כן צריך להבין בפסוק זה מה הוראת דרך יש כאן
"And if so, we need to understand what showing of the way there is in this verse."
Me'or Einayim, Vayeshev 1Open the source

One teaching, seven days

The Me'or Einayim has one short teaching on Parshat Vayeshev. In the text on Sefaria (an online library of Jewish texts) it is five paragraphs long. This week's seven days follow it in his order. From the verse he turns to why the world was created, then to a Mishnah (a teaching from the first written code of the Oral Torah) about servants and reward, then to how a world with limits can exist, then to why the Torah has stories in it at all, then to the Exodus from Egypt. Only then does he read the verse.

Sources

Share on WhatsApp
Monday, November 30 · Day 2 of 7

It Is the Nature of Good to Do Good

Why is there a world at all? The Me'or Einayim (Rabbi Menachem Nachum of Chernobyl) first rules out one answer: it was not because Hashem (God) needed one.

2 minute read
Think first

A person who needs something is missing it. That is what needing is. Hashem (God) is missing nothing. So why would He create a world? What could a world be for?

Today's teaching

The Sages say the world was created "for the sake of the Torah and for the sake of Israel." The Me'or Einayim explains. The whole purpose of the creation, he says, was only to do good to His creatures. Hashem (God) did not need a world for Himself. A person who needs a thing lacks it, and no lack applies to Him. Rather, it is the nature of the good to do good, as the verse says, "Hashem is good to all." So He created the worlds, so that the creatures could enjoy His goodness. And the main good, he says, is the delight Israel take in doing His mitzvot (commandments). In this they delight in Hashem, and then He too receives delight, like a father who delights in his child.

Read it in his wordsThe Me'or Einayim in Hebrew, with our English
רק כוונת הבריאה היתה כי מטבע הטוב להטיב כמו שאמר הכתוב (תהלים קמ״ה, ט׳) טוב ה׳ לכל גו׳ ועל כן ברא העולמות לשיוכלו הבריות ליהנות מטובו
"…rather, the creation was intended because it is the nature of the good to do good, as the verse says (Tehillim [Psalms] 145:9), 'Hashem is good to all,' and so on. And so He created the worlds, so that the creatures could enjoy His goodness."
Me'or Einayim, Vayeshev 2Open the source
Take it to work

When you give, notice what you wanted back

On Thursday you bought the coffees. Four of them, one with oat milk, carried back in a cardboard tray with your thumb in one of them. Nobody asked you to. By the elevator you had worked out who would mention it, and in which meeting. By your desk you were a little hurt by the one who took the oat milk and said, "Oh. Nice."

The Me'or Einayim describes a giving that does not come from need. Hashem did not need a world, he says: to need a thing is to lack it, and He lacks nothing. There is a world because it is the nature of the good to do good, and the creatures are there to enjoy it.

In our words: he is speaking of the Creator, and you are not that. A person needs things. You needed the coffee. We borrow only a question for the tray: how much of it was the good doing good, and how much was a purchase? Probably both. In his parable a father delights in his child. A person can want that delight and still be giving. The oat milk was, by all accounts, enjoyed.

Today's move

Do one useful thing for a colleague today and tell no one, the colleague included. Notice what you still wanted from it.

Send to a friend

Ask yourself, or your study partnerWhen I give, what am I usually hoping to get back?

Go deeperMore of the teaching, and every source

For the Torah and for Israel

The saying he starts from is quoted by Rashi, the classic commentator, on the first verse of the Torah, as the reading of the Sages: the world was created for the sake of the Torah, which is called "the beginning [reishit] of His way" (Mishlei, Proverbs, 8:22), and for the sake of Israel, who are called "the beginning of His harvest" (Yirmiyahu, Jeremiah, 2:3). The Me'or Einayim returns to the two halves of the saying in the third paragraph. He writes both "the world" and "the worlds." In Kabbalah (the hidden teachings of the Torah) the creation has many levels, and each is called a world. That note is ours.

Not out of need

אבל השם יתברך אינו כן כי הוא שלם בכל מיני השלימות ולא יפול עליו שום חסרון ח״ו עד שנאמר שהיה צריך לבריאת העולמות
"But Hashem, blessed be He, is not so, for He is whole in every kind of wholeness, and no lack applies to Him, Heaven forbid, that we should say He needed the creation of the worlds."
Me'or Einayim, Vayeshev 2Open the source

The main good

ועיקר הטוב הוא מה שמתענגין ישראל בעשיית מצוותיו ובזה מתענגים על ה׳ ואז גם הוא מקבל תענוג מזה כמו שאמרו רז״ל ישראל מפרנסים לאביהם שבשמים כמשל האב שמתענג בילד שעשועיו
"And the main good is that Israel delight in doing His mitzvot, and in this they delight in Hashem, and then He too receives delight from it, as the Sages said, 'Israel sustain their Father in Heaven,' like a father who delights in his darling child."
Me'or Einayim, Vayeshev 2Open the source

"Israel sustain their Father in Heaven" is in the Zohar (the classic of Kabbalah) on the Torah portion Vayikra (3:7b), which quotes it as something already taught: "we have learned." The Zohar says it there about the offerings. "Delight in Hashem" is the language of Yeshayahu (Isaiah) 58:14, "Then you will delight in Hashem." "Darling child" is yeled sha'ashuim, words said through the prophet about the people of Ephraim, in Yirmiyahu 31:19 (31:20 in many editions, Sefaria's among them).

Sources

Share on WhatsApp
Tuesday, December 1 · Day 3 of 7

The Good Is the Doing of the Mitzvah

A famous teaching of the Sages says not to serve for a reward, and then seems to say it again. The Me'or Einayim (Rabbi Menachem Nachum of Chernobyl) asks what the second half adds.

2 minute read
Think first

The Mishnah (the first written code of the Oral Torah) says: "Do not be like servants who serve the master in order to receive a reward. Rather, be like servants who serve the master not in order to receive a reward." The second half sounds like a repeat. What might it add?

Today's teaching

The Me'or Einayim asks why the Mishnah says it twice. He answers from yesterday's step: a person needs to delight in doing Hashem's (God's) mitzvot (commandments), a spiritual delight that is a taste of the World to Come (the world of reward after this one). The first half, he says: the service should not be for a reward that comes after it, with an eye on the World to Come. Rather, at once, while the mitzvah is being done, a spiritual delight should be stirred from above. And the second half: not "in order to" at all, meaning some good received afterward. The good is the doing of the mitzvah itself.

Read it in his wordsThe Me'or Einayim in Hebrew, with our English
אלא הטובה הוא העסק במצוה גופיה ותיכף שעוסק יתענג על ה׳
"…rather, the good is the doing of the mitzvah itself, and as soon as he is engaged in it, he should delight in Hashem."
Me'or Einayim, Vayeshev 2Open the source
Take it to work

Some good is in the doing, not after it

Your bonus is decided in February. You know this because your spreadsheet has a tab called Feb. Since September, every hard thing you do at work has gone under that tab: the Sunday slides, the eleven p.m. call. You do them the way a person feeds a parking meter. Then one afternoon you untangled a colleague's spreadsheet, looked up, and it was dark out. You never filed that one. There was no tab for it.

The Me'or Einayim reads the Mishnah as speaking of mitzvot. The service, he says, should not be for a payment that comes afterward. The good is the doing of the mitzvah itself, and that, he says, is when a person is to delight in Hashem.

In our words: a job is not the mitzvot he is speaking of. Take the bonus. We borrow only the question of where the good is: after the work, or in it. Most of your week is paid in February. But you know the other kind: the afternoon it got dark. Has anything in your davening (prayer) or your learning ever felt like that? Or is it all going under a tab too, possibly one called Later?

Today's move

Pick one mitzvah you will do today anyway: a blessing, a prayer, ten minutes of learning. Do it slowly enough to notice any delight in it.

Send to a friend

Ask yourself, or your study partnerWhat do I do for the doing itself, and is any mitzvah on that list?

Go deeperMore of the teaching, and every source

The Mishnah

The Mishnah is Pirkei Avot (Ethics of the Fathers) 1:3. It is the saying of Antigonus of Socho, who received the tradition from Shimon the Righteous, and it ends: "and let the fear of Heaven be upon you."

His question

דלכאורה הוא שפת יתר דמכלל שאמר אל תהיו וכו׳ ממילא נשמע דצריך להיות שלא על מנת לקבל פרס ולמה חזר ושנה בסיפא
"…for at first glance the words are extra. Once it has said 'do not be,' and so on, we understand by ourselves that it has to be 'not in order to receive a reward.' Why did it go back and teach this in the second half?"
Me'or Einayim, Vayeshev 2Open the source

At once

כלומר שלא יהיה העבודה לקבל שכר אחר זה ולצפות לתשלום שכר עולם הבא מה שיהיה אחר כך אלא תיכף בעת עשיית המצוה יתעורר תענוג רוחני מלמעלה עליכם
"…that is, the service should not be in order to receive a reward after it, looking ahead to the payment of the reward of the World to Come, which will be afterward. Rather, at once, at the time the mitzvah is done, a spiritual delight should be stirred upon you from above."
Me'or Einayim, Vayeshev 2Open the source

Note his words about the reward of the World to Come: it "will be afterward." What he says the service should not be is service for the sake of it.

And one who still serves for a reward

This is not from the Me'or Einayim's teaching. The Rambam (Maimonides), in his Laws of Repentance (10:5), calls learning Torah in order to receive a reward "not for its own sake," and quotes a saying of the Sages about it. The saying is in the Gemara (the Talmud, Pesachim 50b), where Rav Yehudah says in the name of Rav: a person should always occupy himself with Torah and mitzvot even not for their own sake, because out of doing them not for their own sake he comes to do them for their own sake.

Sources

Share on WhatsApp
Wednesday, December 2 · Day 4 of 7

A World Has Edges

Hashem (God) has no limit. The world does. The Me'or Einayim (Rabbi Menachem Nachum of Chernobyl) asks how the One could create the other.

2 minute read
Think first

Hashem (God) is without limit. A world is a thing with limits: this large, this long, here and not there. How could One with no limit create something that has them?

Today's teaching

The Me'or Einayim now explains the Sages' saying he quoted earlier, that the world was created "for the sake of the Torah and for the sake of Israel." First, the Torah. Hashem (God) is without limit, he says. How, then, could He create the world, which has a limit? By means of the Torah, he answers, as the verse says, "You have clothed Yourself in glory and majesty." Through this He contracted His Shechinah (His presence that dwells in the world), so that there could be boundary and limit in the world. Then, Israel. The whole intent of the creation, he says, was for Israel: that they walk in Hashem's Torah and receive the complete good he has described.

Read it in his wordsThe Me'or Einayim in Hebrew, with our English
דהנה השם יתברך הוא בלתי בעל תכלית ואיך יכול לברוא העולם שהוא בעל תכלית אך הוא על ידי התורה כמו שכתוב (תהלים ק״ד, א׳) הוד והדר לבשת ועל ידי זה צמצם שכינתו שיוכל להיות בעולם גבול ותכלית
"…for Hashem, blessed be He, is without limit. How, then, could He create the world, which has a limit? But it is by means of the Torah, as it is written (Tehillim [Psalms] 104:1), 'You have clothed Yourself in glory and majesty,' and through this He contracted His Shechinah [His presence], so that there could be boundary and limit in the world."
Me'or Einayim, Vayeshev 3Open the source
Take it to work

A plan needs edges before it can be anything

There is a document on your laptop called Ideas MASTER. It is forty-one pages long. It holds a podcast, a nonprofit, two apps, a plan to finish Shas (the whole Talmud), and one line that says only "kayaks??" Nothing in it has ever failed, because nothing in it has ever been anything. It has no dates, no budget and no first step. It is the most promising thing you own.

The Me'or Einayim asks how Hashem, who is without limit, could create a world, which has limits. By means of the Torah, he says, and he quotes a verse about clothing. Through this His Shechinah was contracted, so that the world could have boundary and limit.

In our words: he is speaking of the Creator and of how there came to be a world, and nothing in a document is like that. What follows is ours, and it is small. A plan is not a world. A plan is nothing yet until it has edges. The line that says "kayaks??" has no date and no price. Give it both, and it is an actual thing, possibly involving one kayak. That is the only version that will ever be on the water.

Today's move

Open your longest list of ideas. Give one of them a date, a cost and a first step that takes under an hour.

Send to a friend

Ask yourself, or your study partnerWhich of my plans has no date, no cost and no first step?

Go deeperMore of the teaching, and every source

For Israel

וכל עיקר כוונת הבריאה היה בשביל ישראל שילכו בתורת ה׳ ויקבלו הטוב הגמור כאמור
"And the whole main intent of the creation was for Israel, that they walk in the Torah of Hashem and receive the complete good, as was said."
Me'or Einayim, Vayeshev 3Open the source

"As was said" points back to the second paragraph, where the main good is the delight Israel take in doing the mitzvot (commandments). The verse about clothing is Tehillim (Psalms) 104:1: "…Hashem my God, You are very great; You have clothed Yourself in glory and majesty." The saying about the Torah and Israel is quoted by Rashi, the classic commentator, on Bereishit (Genesis) 1:1.

Contracted

His word is tzimtzem, "He contracted." The idea it names, tzimtzum, is a large subject in Kabbalah (the hidden teachings of the Torah). The Me'or Einayim gives it here in one line.

His next question

The fourth paragraph opens with a question: the Torah should have begun with its mitzvot. Why was it clothed in stories? That is the next step.

Sources

Share on WhatsApp
Thursday, December 3 · Day 5 of 7

The Everyday Talk of the Righteous

Why does the Torah begin with stories and not with its mitzvot (commandments)? The Me'or Einayim (Rabbi Menachem Nachum of Chernobyl) answers by way of the everyday talk of the righteous.

2 minute read
Think first

The Sages say that even the everyday talk of Torah scholars "needs study." Nobody can learn Torah every minute; people talk about ordinary things too. What could there be to study in how a great person talks about ordinary things?

Today's teaching

The Torah, the Me'or Einayim says, should have begun with its mitzvot. Why was it clothed in stories? His answer goes by way of a saying of the Sages: the everyday talk of Torah scholars needs study. It is impossible, he says, to learn Torah all the time, and a person has to speak of physical things. But when tzaddikim (the righteous) speak even of physical things, they are attached to Hashem (God), and their talk is truly Torah. By it they raise souls, as by learning Torah. Some souls, he says, can be raised by such words more than by learning.

Read it in his wordsThe Me'or Einayim in Hebrew, with our English
וממש שיחתן תורה היא כי מעלים בזה נשמות כמו בעסק התורה ויש נשמות שיכולים להתעלות בדבורים יותר מבעסק התורה שאין להם כח להתכלל בתורה ולהתעלות עם התורה רק עם הדבור הגשמי
"…and their talk [the talk of the righteous] is truly Torah, for by it they raise souls, as by the study of Torah. And there are souls that can be raised by words more than by the study of Torah, for they do not have the strength to be included in the Torah and to rise with the Torah, only with physical speech."
Me'or Einayim, Vayeshev 4Open the source
Take it to work

The small talk is not outside what counts

Your Thursday call with your manager is thirty minutes long, and the first four are about nothing: the weather in two cities, his dog, whether your camera has frozen. You have timed this. You think of the four minutes as a tax. Last week he was away, and someone else ran the call and started on time. It was very efficient. Afterward you noticed you did not know how anyone was.

The Me'or Einayim takes the everyday talk of tzaddikim seriously. Nobody can learn Torah all the time, he says; a person has to speak of physical things. But when tzaddikim speak of them, they are attached to Hashem, and their talk is truly Torah. It raises souls, he says, and some it can raise more than learning can.

In our words: your manager is not the tzaddik of this teaching, as far as anyone knows, and neither are you. In his words, the tzaddikim are attached to Hashem while they talk, and their talk raises souls. That is a high bar for a work call. We borrow something lower: the four minutes are not outside what counts. Ask about the dog. Its name, it turns out, is Brisket.

Today's move

In one conversation today, do not hurry the small talk. Ask one ordinary question and listen to the whole answer.

Send to a friend

Ask yourself, or your study partnerWhose everyday talk leaves people a little better, and what exactly do they do?

Go deeperMore of the teaching, and every source

Why stories?

The Torah, he writes, should have begun with its mitzvot. And he asks:

ולמה נתלבשה בסיפורי מעשיות
"…and why was it clothed in stories?"
Me'or Einayim, Vayeshev 4Open the source

Rashi, the classic commentator, opens his commentary on the Torah with a question close to this one, in the name of Rabbi Yitzchak: the Torah needed to begin only from "This month shall be for you" (Shemot, Exodus, 12:2), the first mitzvah that Israel was commanded. Rashi gives a different answer there. The Me'or Einayim answers from the mitzvah to tell of the Exodus, and from the saying about the talk of Torah scholars.

Needs study

The saying is in the Gemara (the Talmud, Avodah Zarah 19b) in the name of Rav: even the everyday talk of Torah scholars needs study. It is learned from a verse about the person whose desire is in Hashem's Torah. He is like a tree that gives its fruit in its season, "and whose leaf does not wither" (Tehillim, Psalms, 1:3). Nearly the same saying is in Sukkah 21b. "The righteous walk in them" is from Hoshea (Hosea) 14:10: "…for the ways of Hashem are straight, and the righteous walk in them…"

Nobody can learn all the time

כי בודאי אי אפשר ללמוד תורה תמיד וצריך לדבר דברים גשמיים וצדיקים ילכו בם כשמדברים אפילו דברים גשמיים
"…for certainly it is impossible to learn Torah always, and one has to speak of physical things. 'And the righteous walk in them': when they speak even of physical things…"
Me'or Einayim, Vayeshev 4Open the source

He goes on: they are then attached to Hashem, and their talk is truly Torah. The lines that follow are in "Read it in his words," above.

Sources

Share on WhatsApp
Friday, December 4 · Day 6 of 7

Tell It All Year

The Haggadah (the text read at the Seder, on the night of Pesach, Passover) praises "whoever tells more" of the Exodus from Egypt. The Me'or Einayim (Rabbi Menachem Nachum of Chernobyl) says "more" means all year, in whatever a person is saying.

2 minute read
Think first

At the Pesach Seder we read: "Whoever tells more of the Exodus from Egypt is praiseworthy." What do you think "more" means? A longer Seder? Or something else?

Today's teaching

What is the "more" of "whoever tells more"? The Me'or Einayim has just said that the everyday talk of tzaddikim (the righteous) is Torah and raises souls. This, he says, is the idea of yetziat Mitzrayim, the going out of Egypt. He reads Mitzrayim, Egypt, as meitzar yam, the edge of the sea, and explains: close to the shore of the sea of true wisdom. And so it is a mitzvah (commandment) to tell of the Exodus always. At every hour, when a person speaks of anything, his words should be "in the Exodus from Egypt." That is "whoever tells more": not only on Pesach.

Read it in his wordsThe Me'or Einayim in Hebrew, with our English
וזה ענין יציאת מצרים מלשון מיצר ים רצה לומר סמוך לשפת ים החכמה האמיתית ולכן מצוה לספר תמיד ביציאת מצרים פירוש בכל עת ובכל שעה כשמדבר איזה דבר יהיה דבריו ביציאת מצרים
"And this is the idea of yetziat Mitzrayim, from the words meitzar yam, which is to say: close to the shore of the sea of true wisdom. And so it is a mitzvah to tell always of the Exodus from Egypt, meaning: at every time and at every hour, when one speaks of anything, his words should be in the Exodus from Egypt."
Me'or Einayim, Vayeshev 4Open the source
Take it to work

Ordinary words can be said from close to what is true

A person says several thousand words a day. Of yours, yesterday, some were davening (prayer) and some were Torah. A surprising number concerned a parking spot. The rest were work: "circling back," "per my last email," "sounds good." You said "sounds good" eleven times. Three of those things did not sound good.

The Me'or Einayim reads a line of the Haggadah as reaching all of those words. It is a mitzvah to tell of the Exodus always, he says, not only on Pesach: when a person speaks of anything, his words should be "in the Exodus." In Mitzrayim he hears meitzar yam: close to the shore of the sea of true wisdom.

In our words: he has just been describing how tzaddikim (the righteous) talk, and this page is not asking you to raise the ten plagues in a team meeting. How a sentence about a parking spot comes to be "in the Exodus" is more than this page knows. We borrow only his shore. The rest is ours: some words are said from close to what is true, and some from far off. "Sounds good," about a thing that does not, is said from far off. Eight of yours were fine.

Today's move

Before Shabbat, catch one phrase you say all day without meaning it. Next time, say it only if it is true.

Send to a friend

Ask yourself, or your study partnerHow much of what I said this week was close to what is true?

Go deeperMore of the teaching, and every source

Whoever tells more

דמצוה עלינו לספר ביציאת מצרים כמו שאמר בעל הגדה וכל המרבה לספר ביציאת מצרים הרי זה משובח
"…for it is a mitzvah upon us to tell of the Exodus from Egypt, as the author of the Haggadah said: 'And whoever tells more of the Exodus from Egypt is praiseworthy.'"
Me'or Einayim, Vayeshev 4Open the source

The line is in the passage "We were slaves to Pharaoh in Egypt," near the start of the Haggadah: "Even if all of us were wise, all of us understanding, all of us elders, all of us knowing the Torah, it would be a mitzvah upon us to tell of the Exodus from Egypt."

Not only on Pesach

וזהו וכל המרבה כו׳ דלאו דווקא בפסח אלא אפילו תמיד יהיה סיפורו ביציאת מצרים
"And this is 'whoever tells more,' and so on: not only on Pesach. Rather, always, his telling should be of the Exodus from Egypt."
Me'or Einayim, Vayeshev 4Open the source

In halachah (Jewish law) the Exodus is in any case mentioned every day and every night, in the Shema (the daily declaration that begins "Hear, Israel"). The Mishnah (the first written code of the Oral Torah, Berachot 1:5) gives Ben Zoma's reading of the verse "so that you remember the day you left the land of Egypt all the days of your life" (Devarim, Deuteronomy, 16:3): "the days of your life" are the days, and "all" adds the nights. The Haggadah quotes this Mishnah a few lines after "whoever tells more." The Me'or Einayim's "always" is wider: "when one speaks of anything."

The edge of the sea

Mitzrayim is written mem, tzadi, resh, yud, mem. The first three letters spell meitzar, a border or a narrow place, and the last two spell yam, sea. "The sea of true wisdom" is his phrase.

Sources

Share on WhatsApp
Shabbat, December 5 · Day 7 of 7

What the Coat Spells

The teaching began with a verse and left it. In his last lines the Me'or Einayim (Rabbi Menachem Nachum of Chernobyl) comes back: Yisrael, Yosef and the coat.

For the Shabbat table. Print it on Friday.

2 minute read
Think first

The verse says Yisrael loved Yosef "for he was a son of his old age, and he made him a ketonet passim," a special coat. All week the Me'or Einayim has spoken of delight in mitzvot (commandments) and of the talk of the righteous. In his reading, who might Yisrael and Yosef be?

Today's teaching

Now he reads the verse. The Zohar (the classic of Kabbalah, the Torah's hidden teachings), he says, calls Hashem (God) Yisrael Sabba, "Israel the Elder." Yosef is the tzaddik (the righteous person), who is always adding, mosif, in the fear of Heaven, to raise lower levels up to Hashem. "A son of his old age" is, in the Aramaic translation of Onkelos, "a wise son": he raises all the souls by his speech. And the ketonet passim: the tzaddik, he says, makes garments for Hashem, in which Hashem clothes Himself. Passim, he says, is the first letters of peh sach yetziat Mitzrayim, "a mouth that tells the going out of Egypt." His last word on it is "understand."

Read it in his wordsThe Me'or Einayim in Hebrew, with our English
ועשה לו כתונת פסים כי הצדיק עושה להשם יתברך לבושין במה שיתלבש בו השם יתברך פסי״ם הוא ראשי תיבות ״פה ״סח ״יציאת ״מצרים
"'And he made him a ketonet passim': for the tzaddik makes garments for Hashem, blessed be He, in which Hashem, blessed be He, clothes Himself. Passim is the first letters of peh sach yetziat Mitzrayim [a mouth that tells the going out of Egypt]."
Me'or Einayim, Vayeshev 5Open the source
Take it to the Shabbat table

Listen to what your table is talking about

Before you say anything, listen to the table. At the far end, a parking story. In the middle, the story of how the hosts met. Near you, a long account of a delayed flight to Newark, told with real feeling. Three conversations are going, and the soup is excellent.

The Me'or Einayim ends his teaching at a coat. Yisrael, in his reading, is Hashem, and Yosef is the tzaddik, who raises souls by his speech. The coat, he says, is the garments a tzaddik makes for Hashem. And passim spells out a mouth that tells the going out of Egypt.

In our words: he is describing a tzaddik, and a table of tired people is not that. We borrow only the picture of a garment: what gets said at a meal is what the meal ends up wearing. The Friday night meal opens with words of its own: Kiddush (the words over wine that declare the day holy), which has in it "a remembrance of the going out of Egypt." After that it is up to the table. One real question usually does it. The flight to Newark can land.

This Shabbat

At a Shabbat meal, ask one question people have to think about before answering. Then let the table have it.

Send to a friend

Ask yourself, or your study partnerWhat does our table usually talk about, and what would I want it known for?

Look back at your week

Which move actually stuck?

Pick the one you will keep doing. Moves you marked "I did it" have a check.

Go deeperMore of the teaching, and every source

Yisrael and Yosef

דהנה איתא בזוהר הקדוש דהשם יתברך נקרא ישראל סבא ויוסף הוא הצדיק כי תמיד מוסיף ביראת שמים להעלות מדריגות תחתונות אליו יתברך
"…for it says in the holy Zohar that Hashem, blessed be He, is called Yisrael Sabba, and Yosef is the tzaddik, for he is always adding in the fear of Heaven, to raise lower levels to Him, blessed be He."
Me'or Einayim, Vayeshev 5Open the source

The name Yisrael Sabba, "Israel the Elder," is found in the Zohar in a number of places. One of them is its reading of the verse "Hear, Israel," in the Torah portion Vayakhel. Yosef was named for adding: "She called his name Yosef, saying: May Hashem add [yosef] another son for me" (Bereishit, Genesis, 30:24).

A wise son

כי בן זקונים הוא לו ותרגום אונקלוס ארי בר חכים הוא ליה פירוש שמעלה כל הנשמות בדבורו וכולם בחכמה אתברירו
"'For he was a son of his old age': and Targum Onkelos has, 'for he was a wise son to him,' meaning that he raises all the souls by his speech, and 'all of them are sifted in wisdom.'"
Me'or Einayim, Vayeshev 5Open the source

Targum Onkelos is the classic Aramaic translation of the Torah. On Bereishit 37:3 it translates "a son of his old age" as bar chakim, "a wise son." "All of them are sifted in wisdom" is an Aramaic line that later books quote in these words. It goes back to the Zohar on the Torah portion Pekudei (2:254b), which speaks there of sifting "from within thought."

Back to the first question

At the start he asked what way this verse shows. The last paragraph begins, "And this is 'Yisrael loved Yosef,'" and closes with "and understand" and a blessing. The steps between were these. The world was created so that Hashem could do good to His creatures. The main good is the delight Israel take in doing the mitzvot (commandments), at the time they are done. A world with limits came to be by means of the Torah. The Torah itself was clothed in stories. The everyday talk of tzaddikim is truly Torah, and raises souls. And so it is a mitzvah to tell of the Exodus always.

Kiddush

The Friday night Kiddush mentions the going out of Egypt. In the Gemara (the Talmud, Pesachim 117b), Rav Acha bar Yaakov says that it must be mentioned, and the Torah ties Shabbat to the Exodus in Devarim (Deuteronomy) 5:15. This connection is ours, not the Me'or Einayim's.

Talk at a Shabbat table

The card describes a table. It does not rule on what may be said at one. The Sages learn from a verse (Yeshayahu, Isaiah, 58:13) that a person's speech on Shabbat should not be like his speech on a weekday (Shabbat 113a-b), and the Shulchan Aruch (the standard code of Jewish law), Orach Chaim 307:1, sets out what that covers. What it means for your own table is a question for your rav (rabbi).

Sources

Share on WhatsApp

Free, Sunday to Friday

Get the daily dose by email

One short email a day with that day's teaching and a link to read it here. Friday's email includes the Shabbat dose. Unsubscribe anytime.

The Hebrew of the Me'or Einayim and of every other source is from Sefaria. The quotes are short excerpts. We do not quote everything in each paragraph, and we write the name of God with a kuf. English renderings, explanations and the "Take it to work" applications are Torah Tech originals, and any mistakes are ours.

This page is for learning. It is not a halachic ruling. For practical questions, ask your rav.

Torah Tech · torahtech.co/meor · The Opportunity Year in Tel Aviv · Learn more and apply at torahtech.co
The Opportunity Year · Tel Aviv, Israel

Learn like this for a year

Torah Tech is a beit midrash in Tel Aviv built for personal and professional growth: Torah learning at the center of every day, and internships at Israeli startups. It is the year a future Jewish leader realizes who he can become, and chooses to become it.